Are Angi and Thumbtack leads worth it?
By Pamela Chance, Founder and CEO, TheFullRoute.com by Chance Catalyst
How do shared leads work?
You pay for a homeowner's request, and other contractors may get the same request.
The customer fills out one form. The platform sends it to several pros in the area. Everyone gets the same name and number at about the same time. Then it is a race. The first contractor to call or text back usually gets the conversation, and often the job.
Why do so many contractors hate them?
Because you pay whether you win the job or not, and you're usually busy when the lead comes in.
The lead shows up while you are on a job. By the time you can call back, the customer has talked to two other companies. Some leads are price shoppers, some are wrong numbers, and some are outside your area. You still paid for each one.
How fast do I need to respond?
As fast as you possibly can. Minutes, not hours.
The customer just asked for help. They are holding their phone. The first contractor who reaches them with a real answer has the best shot. If your reply goes out an hour later, the customer has often already booked with someone else.
How do I know if they're worth it for me?
Track every lead for one month: what it cost, whether you reached them, and whether it turned into a job.
At the end of the month, add up what you spent on leads and what you earned from the jobs they produced. Look at how many leads you never reached at all. If most of your losses came from slow replies, the leads may be fine. Your response time is the problem.
Are there ways to make shared leads pay off?
Yes: answer instantly, ask good questions, and book the visit before anyone else does.
Reply within a minute with a real message, not a generic one. Ask what is going on and where they are. Offer a time to come out. Check that they are in your service area before you drive anywhere. The goal is to be the first real, useful answer the customer gets.
Should I quit the lead services?
Not necessarily. Use them while you build your own steady flow of calls.
Shared leads cost money every time. Your own Google reviews, your own website and repeat customers on maintenance plans do not. Many shops keep lead services as a supplement while they build up the work that comes straight to them.
Where does TheFullRoute.com fit?
TheFullRoute.com answers your Angi, Thumbtack and HomeAdvisor leads in seconds, even when you're on a job.
Trey, our AI assistant, replies to the new lead right away, asks what the customer needs, checks your service area and works to book the visit. You get a text with the details. You stop losing paid leads to the shop that happened to be free.